I'm going by a 1-10 scale. I'll be rating by the following criteria:

On-Point - Did the comic follow the rules of the contest?
Personal Enjoyment - How much did I enjoy the comic?
Presentation - Did the way the comic presented itself suit the comic?
Tilt - Extra points given willy-nilly, depending on what I thought was important in the comic.

So the maximum score is 40/40. Alto, feel free to rate them on whatever scale you want.

Here's my prelim scores:


Spacing for Alto's virgin eyes:









1ce - "Waiting for Acre-age"

OP - 10
PE - 7
P - 7
T - 6

Final - 30/40

1ce/Staffy - "Flowers"

OP - 0
PE - 8
P - 8
T- 4

Final - 20/40

Lantis - "Hide and Seek"

OP - 10
PE - 10
P - 8
T - 8

Final - 36/40

The Gnasher - "How to be a successful RPG character"

OP - 10
PE - 8
P - 9
T - 7

Final - 34/40

Regal - "The Magonian Avatar Costume Party"

OP - 10
PE - 10
P - 9
T - 8

Final - 37/40

I picked Regal's entry for the win because it was followed the topic guidelines well, delved into the community, plucked out some nice comprehensive nuggets, and gave it an opportunity to be enjoyable to people even outside the Magonian community.



Staffy - "Magpies 1.9.1"

OP - 10
PE - 8
P - 9
T - 8

Final - 35/40

Sumisem - "The Magpire"

OP - 10
PE - 9
P - 8
T - 9

Final - 36/40

1.) Plot:

2.) Was I impressed by the creativity and the scale of said impression:

3.) How well the length was for the comic:

4.) How purty was it:


1ce:
1.) 2
2.) 3
3.) 10
4.) 4
Total: 19

1ce/Staff:
1.) 4
2.) 4
3.) 7
4.) 3
Total: 18

Lantis:
1.) 7
2.) 6
3.) 8
4.) 7
Total: 28

Gnasher:
1.) 7
2.) 9
3.) 7
4.) 8
Total: 31

Regal:
1.) 6
2.) 9
3.) 8
4.) 7
Total: 30

Staffy:
1.) 2
2.) 8
3.) 5
4.) 10
Total: 25

Sumisem:
1.) 5
2.) 5
3.) 4
4.) 5
Total: 19

We decided together that Regal won. Any questions? If so ask away and I will answer to the best of my ability.

congrats Regal.

My question is....

whens the next contest?
*audience laughs*

Wish I had known that a one-panel comic would've been okay. I would've definately entered... but I'll save that idea for later.

I'll win next time.

^ i look forward to it.

also *joy*

sorry i didn't post before, i was home for the weekend...

Hey, I did better than I thought! I'll win next time for sure!

Well well, thank you for your ratings ^^

It's always fun to write a comic.

Though mine was hugely full of copyrighted material...